Search blog.co.uk

TheirTube...

by ajnspencer @ 03/07/08 - 19:15:52

Well, if you've ever watched a YouTube video Viacom will soon know which one you watched and who you are, your login and IP address.

Their currently suing Google after finding clips of their shows on the site and things have turned nasty in a move the digital rights group the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) called a "set-back to privacy rights" and "overreaching".

Amazingly this isn't locked in to who uploaded or viewed their copyrighted clips but everything on YouTube.

I thought the majority of companies had taken the logical line when it came to video sharing, most music companies have their own logins and then get to pound us with adverts.

They even have identifiers now that recognise songs in videos and put the ads in automatically, my last Bloscars vid had ads because it was recognised as Mika, they didn't mind me using it, as long as the ads were there.

I'd also argue that for things like TV shows, will Viacom's profits be hindered... or helped by this?

Personally I've seen clips on YouTube that have prompted me buying DVDs, I've seen clips that have made me watch shows.

With the limited length of YouTube clips do they really think you'll be bored enough to watch an entire show in short clips?

But here we are, Viacom are suing, the Premier League are trying for a class action suit because of footy highlights and it's no longer something the big companies are fighting over, now it's personal...

It's interesting this won't happen right now because of various complaints by privacy companies and Google themselves who are arguing the ruling...

What concerns me is this opens a door, they don't know how long you viewed a clip for, maybe you just skipped past it while stumbling or surfing, they just know you watched it...

I find it hard to believe it'll be TOO problematic as, to be fair, are they REALLY going to trace even the 1.5 billion IP addresses they sa have viewed their copyrighted clips? I'd suggest no.

But it opens an interesting gateway if it goes ahead. We often surf not thinking we're leaving indelible footprints in the way of our IP addresses, does this open up a way for companies everywhere to ask for a list of them at any grievance?

It'll probably come to nothing but I find it a little concerning.

Comments: Hide subcomments

What will happen is what always happens: There will be a fee arrangement, through advertisers, and Viacom will be happy.

It's not about copyright infringement at all (well, not substantially) - it's about Google getting increasingly away with industrial murder all in the name of not being "evil" while making billions and billions and billions merely by pointing out where other (creative) people upload their stuff, while the creators don't get a slice of the pie.

I love Google to bits - I really do - but they have to share their spoils, and there's a lot of spoil to share.

See, I'm with you on that, that's why I think the embedded ad thing is a good idea. I'm surprised though that part of their battle is wanting to see what EVERYONE is watching...

Wouldn't mind so much if it was only who'd seen THEIR stuff.

I admit my jaw dropped when I read about this earlier. It simply makes no sense to me. Maybe I'm missing the point. I see no point in obtaining the IPs of people who have viewed anything on there. It's on there, that makes it free to view. Surely it just makes more sense for everything that is loaded on to be checked for copyright issues?

Meh. I just don't want that Chuckle Brothers clip to come back and bite me in the ass.

"Mr Spencer, you've been charged with watching silly cat movies 4,065,145,921 times..."

Well yes, good idea because I'll be able to network with all the fans of Znethru Vlog. Also, let's see, I've put up 21 vids with an average of 60 hits each, now, at (say) $1 a time, I could be... I could be... not giving up the dayjob!

kiki2ukiki2u [Member]
http://www.kikita.blog.co.uk
2008-07-09 @ 23:20

I didn't know about this!!!! And i'm stunned! It's weird, wanting ours IP adresses! Where will or will they stop? :-/

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
All comments except those from the author's friends will be moderated.
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Footer

The content of this website belongs to a private person, blog.co.uk is not responsible for the content of this website.